The wake structures of a bat in flight have a number of characteristics not associated with any of the bird species studied to this point. Unique features include discrete vortex rings generating negative lift at the end of the upstroke at medium and high speeds, each wing generating its own vortex loop,and a systematic variation in the circulation of the start and stop vortices along the wingspan, with increasing strength towards the wing tips. Here we analyse in further detail some previously published data from quantitative measurements of the wake behind a small bat species flying at speeds ranging from 1.5 to 7 m s–1 in a wind tunnel. The data are extended to include both near- and far-wake measurements. The near-/far-wake comparisons show that although the measured peak vorticity of the start and stop vortices decreases with increasing downstream distance from the wing, the total circulation remains approximately constant. As the wake evolves, the diffuse stop vortex shed at the inner wing forms a more concentrated vortex in the far wake. Taken together, the results show that studying the far wake,which has been the standard procedure, nevertheless risks missing details of the wake. Although study of the far wake alone can lead to the misinterpretation of the wake topology, the net, overall circulation of the main wake vortices can be preserved so that approximate momentum balance calculations are not unreasonable within the inevitably large experimental uncertainties.
The wake behind animals may form relatively simple shapes as suggested by numerous bird studies (Hedenström et al., 2006a; Hedenström et al., 2006b; Rosén et al., 2007; Spedding et al.,2003b). On the other hand, the time-varying properties of even fairly simple, three-dimensional model flapping wings can result in very complex pressure distributions on the wing surfaces with a corresponding high complexity of the ensuing wake (Parker et al., 2007; von Ellenrieder et al., 2003). In contrast to the bird wakes, data from bat flight have also shown a rather complex wake pattern[(Hedenström et al.,2007) see also Tian et al. for some preliminary results(Tian et al., 2006)]. The general wake topologies at three different flight speeds (U=1.5, 4 and 6.5 m s–1) have been described by Hedenström and colleagues on the basis of wake velocity and vorticity fields for a small bat species, Glossophaga soricina(Hedenström et al.,2007). At the lowest speed studied, 1.5 m s–1,the wings generate a strong start vortex, shed at the trailing edge of the wing at the beginning of the downstroke(Fig. 1)(Hedenström et al.,2007). As the wing stroke progresses, a trailing tip vortex is shed from the wing tip and there is also a companion trailing vortex, of opposite sign to the tip vortex, shed at the wing root, showing that each wing generates its own vortex loop. At the end of the downstroke the wing goes through a pitch-up motion, flipping the wing upside down, which results in the shedding of a distinct combined stop/start vortex for the down- and upstroke(Fig. 1)(Hedenström et al.,2007). The downstroke generates a downward- and somewhat backward-directed jet, for weight support and some thrust to overcome drag. During the upstroke the wing moves backwards relative to the still air with reversed circulation compared with the downstroke, thus also resulting in a backward- and downward-directed jet, for thrust and some weight support. At the end of the upstroke the wing goes through a pitch-down motion, shedding a combined stop/start vortex for the up- and downstroke(Fig. 1)(Hedenström et al.,2007).
At speeds of 4 and 6.5 m s–1 a dominant start vortex is generated at the beginning of the downstroke at the outer wing, with trailing patches of start vorticity of lower amplitude, shed throughout the downstroke(Hedenström et al., 2007)(see also Results below). At the inner wing the downstroke is initiated by the wings generating an induced upwash followed by a strong start vortex and trailing patches of start vorticity. As at 1.5 m s–1, both tip and root trailing vortices are found(Fig. 1). When the wing reaches the end of the downstroke the inner wing sheds a diffuse stop vortex. The downstroke generates a downward- and backward-directed jet resulting in weight support and thrust. During the upstroke the wing span is reduced but at the end of the upstroke the wing extends and a weak vortex ring, inducing an upwash (Fig. 1), is visible at the outer wing position (Hedenström et al., 2007) (see also Results below). The inner wing sheds negative-signed vorticity throughout the upstroke, associated with a downwash during the upstroke. The upstroke therefore generates weight support for most of its duration, except at the outer wing towards the end of the upstroke.
The more complicated a wake structure, the more likely it is to twist and bend and deform as it evolves in the wake behind the animal. The deformation as vortex elements are immersed in the velocity fields induced by themselves and their neighbours is very likely to increase the geometrical complexity. If these deformations are associated with interactions between either like-signed(pairing and merging) or opposite-signed vortices (cancellation) then the topology will also change. Such interactions could arrest the natural development that would have occurred in an otherwise quiet ambient. For example, the roll-up of wingtip vortices that usually occurs within a few chord lengths of the wing trailing edge behind a steady wing may be modified because elements of other smaller scale structures are incorporated too. This kind of effect varies with Reynolds number (Re=Ul/ν,where l is a characteristic length and ν is the kinematic viscosity) in the range of interest to small birds and bats(10×104–60×104) because the types of vortex shedding on the wing vary with Re, and the thickness of the shed structures also varies (e.g. Ramasamy et al., 2007).
In summary, it is likely that the bird or bat wake gradually becomes less and less representative of what the flow near the wing looked like the further downstream it is observed. It is somewhat remarkable that previous measurements of bird wakes, that were made at downstream distances(x) of approximately 15 mean chord lengths (c) behind the wing trailing edge, could be recognized and modelled at all, and it is still possible that these measured structures had deformed significantly from their original shape [see studies by Spedding and colleagues for wake evolution behind steady airfoils at moderate Re(Spedding, 2003; Spedding et al., 2006)]. Here we present a more detailed analysis of the bat data than previously(Hedenström et al.,2007), including direct comparisons between near(x/c>1.1) and far (x/c>16) wake measurements. This will allow us to evaluate the scope and utility of far-wake measurements in animal studies.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Animals and experimental facility
Two individuals of the tropical species G. soricina (Pallas) were used. This bat is nectar feeding and habitually hovers when feeding,suggesting it is well adapted for slow flight(von Helversen, 1986). The bats were weighed before each experimental run and the average body masses are presented in Table 1. The morphometrics of wing planform were measured from in-flight photos using Image J(http://rsb.info.nih.gov/ij/; Table 1), following the procedures of Pennycuick (Pennycuick,1989) at speed U=5 m s–1.
|Body mass (kg) .||Wing span, b (m) .||Mean chord, c (m) .||Wing area (m2) .||AR .||Wing loading (kg m–2) .|
|Body mass (kg) .||Wing span, b (m) .||Mean chord, c (m) .||Wing area (m2) .||AR .||Wing loading (kg m–2) .|
AR, aspect ratio, b/c
The bats were trained to fly at a feeder (a metal tube, 2 mm in diameter),providing honey-water, suspended from the ceiling of the Lund University wind tunnel (supplementary material Fig. S1)(Pennycuick et al., 1997). Between feeding bouts the bats roosted on a net 6 m upstream from the test section in the wind tunnel settling chamber. They fed spontaneously by flying downstream into the test section, approaching the feeder via a U-turn from the downstream direction. The bats were individually recognized from a video recording showing a rear view. Between experiments, the bats were kept in a room where they could fly freely and had access to fruit, honey-water,Nectar Plus (Nekton, Pforzheim, Germany) and pollen grains ad libitum. The temperature in the wind tunnel and roosting facility was kept at 22–27°C and the humidity in the roosting facility was maintained at >55%. The bats were clock-shifted 12 h so their active (dark)period coincided with lab hours.
Digital particle image velocimetry
Two synchronized high-speed cameras (Redlake, MotionScope PCI 500, 250 Hz,1/1250 s) recorded the bats from side and dorsal views, simultaneously with the DPIV recording during the far-wake experiments. We used infrared illumination (VDI-IR60F, Video Security Inc., Kaohsiung, Taiwan) to avoid disturbing the bats and to minimize interference with the DPIV measurements. The cameras were equipped with infrared filters [Schneider Optics, BW09249 092(89B); Van Nuys, CA, USA] to eliminate the bright green flashes from the laser. Coordinates of digitized points on the wings and body of the bats from the two views were transformed into three-dimensional coordinates by direct linear transformation (DLT), using freely available Matlab® routines(courtesy of Christoph Reinschmidt, http://isbweb.org/software/movanal.html). Based on the movements of these points, wingbeat frequency (f) and amplitude (A) were calculated (a detailed analysis of the kinematics will be presented elsewhere; M.W., L.C.J., A.H., R.v.B. and Y.W., unpublished data).
Before the analysis the dependent variables and the covariate were loge-transformed to remove non-linearity of the data (see below)and skewness in the distribution (Grafen and Hails, 2002). The mean values for the measurements at each combination of conditions were used as the independent data points, which were weighted using the inverse of the standard error of the mean (s.e.m.). The number of data points for each of the factors is presented in the supplementary material as are the resulting degrees of freedom for each test(supplementary material Tables S1–S7). All analyses were performed using SPSS 15.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) with significance level set at 0.05.
We tested for the effect of wing position and sense of circulation (start or stop) on the near-wake streamwise data using a general linear model (GLM)with normalized peak vorticity (|ω|c/U),normalized circulation of the main start or stop vortex(|Γ|/Uc), normalized total positive or negative circulation in the vorticity field(|Γtot|/Uc), or the relative contribution of the main start or stop vortex to the total circulation of start or stop vortices (Γ/Γtot) as dependent variables. The model was constructed using individual as a random factor and sense of circulation (start or stop) and wing position (lz, ly, lx or lr) as fixed factors. Flight speed was used as a covariate and the model included all main effects and all second-order interactions between factors. Using a linear model on loge-transformed data is equivalent to modelling the raw data using a power function. This is reasonable since|Γ|/Uc is expected to be proportional to U–2(Rosén et al., 2007). The same holds for |ω|c/U, which is proportional to |Γ|/Uc (Pearson correlation=0.988).
Differences between near and far wake were determined using the far-wake data and a subset of the near-wake data covering the same speed range. For this test a GLM with the same variables as in the near-wake-only analysis was performed but including wake position (near or far) as a fixed factor.
Differences between the wing tip and wing root vortices in the transverse data were determined using a GLM with normalized peak vorticity(|ω|c/U) or circulation(|Γ|/Uc) of the vortices as dependent variables. Flight speed was set as covariate, vortex type (tip or root) and stroke phase(mid-downstroke, mid-upstroke and beginning of downstroke) as fixed factors and individual as a random factor.
SPSS calculates estimated marginal means (EMMs), which are the model estimates at the mean value of the covariate for the different factors in the model. The EMMs help to illustrate some of the results.
The general wake topologies at three flight speeds: 1.5, 4 and 6.5 m s–1 have been described previously(Hedenström et al.,2007). Composite streamwise [x, z] velocity fields for the near wake at 2, 3, 5 and 7 m s–1 and for the far wake at 5 and 7 m s–1 for the outer (lz) and inner wing (lx)positions are given in Figs 3, 4, 5, 6, selected to complement previously published wakes. In the following section we will emphasize certain characteristics and point out previously undescribed features of the wake.
At U=2 m s–1 the wing motion was similar to that at 1.5 m s–1 (see above), but the upstroke was more vertical relative to still air than at 1.5 m s–1. The wake in the streamwise plane [x, z] contained two start vortices and only one stop vortex, a pattern found both at the inner(Fig. 4) and at the outer wing positions (Fig. 3). This pattern was also found at 2.5 m s–1 for one of the bats,while the other bat displayed the same wake pattern as at 3 m s–1 (see below). At low speeds (1.5–2.5 m s–1) the start and stop vortices in the wake were distinct(Figs 1, 3 and 4), and in contrast to the higher speeds the stop vortex was also distinct at the inner wing position.
For U=3–7 m s–1 the wake followed the same qualitative pattern as described by Hedenström and colleagues(Hedenström et al., 2007)for speeds of 4 and 6.5 m s–1 (see above). At the inner wing(Fig. 4), the beginning of the downstroke was associated with an induced upwash followed by a large start vortex and then trailing patches of start vorticity (ω+). The timing of the inner wing upwash in the stroke cycle was determined by studying the transverse plane [y, z], which showed a downwash at the end of the upstroke and an upwash at the beginning of the downstroke for the inner wing (lx) and body positions (lr). At these higher speeds of 3 to 7 m s–1, the stop vortex shed at the inner wing was more diffuse than at slower speeds, and had a relatively lower circulation,Γ –/Γtot–. A vortex ring producing a weak upward-induced flow is known to be shed at the outer wing at the end of the upstroke(Hedenström et al.,2007), but with an associated vertical force of only 0.4% and 1%of the weight of the animal at 4 and 6.5 m s–1,respectively.
Trends and patterns
The absolute value of the total circulation of start(|Γtot+|) and stop(|Γtot–|) vortices decreased,as did peak vorticity (|ω+| and|ω –|) and circulation of the main start(|Γ+|) and stop(|Γ–|) vortices, with increasing flight speed (Table 2; see supplementary material Figs S3 and S4 for the raw data). Also, the strength of the main start vortex relative to the total circulation of the start vortices(Γ+/Γtot+) in the streamwise plane [x, z] did not change significantly with speed(Table 2). However, when analysing a subset of the near-wake data, we found a significant negative trend in the Γ+/Γtot+ for speeds>3 m s–1 (Table 2).
|.|||ω|c/U .|||Γ|/Uc .|||Γtot|/Uc .||Γ/Γtot .||Γ+/Γtot+ (U>3 m s–1) .|
|.|||ω|c/U .|||Γ|/Uc .|||Γtot|/Uc .||Γ/Γtot .||Γ+/Γtot+ (U>3 m s–1) .|
P-values in bold are significant. ω, vorticity; Γ,circulation; Γ+, circulation of main start vortex in streamwise velocity fields; c, mean chord; subscript tot, total
There were significant differences between the spanwise wing positions(Table 2) with a trend of decreasing strength of the main start (ω+ andΓ +) and stop (ω– andΓ –) vortices in the streamwise plane [x, z]going from the outer wing towards the centre of the body(Fig. 7B). This trend was present in both the near and the far wakes(Fig. 7A). The rate of decrease in strength from the outer wing to the centre of the body differed for the start and stop vortices, as indicated by the significant interaction between the sense of circulation and wing position, with a more pronounced trend for the stop vortex than for the start vortex(Table 2, Fig. 7). However, the total circulation of start (Γtot+) and stop(Γtot–) vortices in the streamwise [x,z] plane did not differ between wing positions(Table 2).
The transverse [y, z] images(Fig. 1) showed a tip vortex as well as a vortex of opposite sense at the wing root (root vortex) at all speeds studied (1.5, 4 and 6.5 m s–1) throughout most of the wingbeat cycle. The ratio between the root and tip vortex strength was approximately 0.5 at the studied speeds. Only at the end of the upstroke was the root vortex absent at speeds of 4 and 6.5 m s–1. At the beginning of the downstroke the `root' vortex was not located at the wing root, but further out on the wing and it migrated towards the wing root as the stroke progressed. Wingbeat phase, as well as the interaction between tip/root and phase, were significant factors in the statistical model, showing that the peak vorticity magnitude and circulation varied over the stroke cycle and did so differently for the tip and the root vortices(Table 3).
|.|||ω|c/U .|||Γ|/Uc .|
|.|||ω|c/U .|||Γ|/Uc .|
P-values in bold are significant. ω, vorticity; Γ,circulation; c, mean chord
The far wake (Figs 5 and 6) showed similar patterns to the near wake, with a few notable differences. The peak vorticity of the main start (ω+) and stop (ω–) vortices was lower in the far wake than in the near wake(Table 4). However, the circulation of the main start and stop vortices was higher in the far wake than in the near wake (Fig. 7A), but there was no difference in the total streamwise [x,z] start or stop circulation between the near and far wake(Table 4). Taken together, this suggests that the strength of the main start and stop vortices in the far wake was higher relative to the total circulation (Γ/Γtot)in the images. However, although there was such a trend in the data, the result was not significant (Fig. 7; Table 4). The difference between near and far wakes was most pronounced for the stop vortices shed at the inner wing (Fig. 7), where the stop vortices, which had a rather diffuse distribution in the near wake (see Fig. 4), had rolled up into a more distinct structure when reaching the far-wake position (Fig. 6). This is manifested in a significant difference in the circulation for the different wing positions between the near and far wakes, as indicated by the interaction between near/far and wing position(Table 4).
|.|||ω|c/U .|||Γ|/Uc .|||Γtot|/Uc .||Γ/Γtot .|
|.|||ω|c/U .|||Γ|/Uc .|||Γtot|/Uc .||Γ/Γtot .|
P-values in bold are significant. ω, vorticity; Γ,circulation; c, mean chord; subscript tot, total
Far wakes miss details observable in near wake
This study allows for a comparison of wake measurements from the near and far wake of the same animal. The results show that there is a difference in the peak vorticity of the main start (ω+) and stop vortices(ω–), with higher values measured in the near wake than in the far wake, as expected based on simple diffusion of vorticity (e.g. Tritton, 1988). The results thus display the same trend as experimental results from fixed wing studies(Spedding et al., 2006). The total circulation in the image of start (Γtot+) or stop (Γtot–) vortices did not differ between the near and far wake (Table 4). This is also in line with previous studies on fixed wings(Spedding et al., 2006), and suggests that it can be informative to study far wakes, as is commonly the case when working on unrestrained live flying animals, but that not all measurements will be affected similarly. The estimates of circulation of the main start and stop vortices showed, somewhat counter-intuitively, higher values in the far wake than in the near wake. This was primarily because the rather diffuse stop vortex shed at the inner wing became more concentrated in the far wake (Fig. 7A). The merger of two like-signed vortices (e.g. Melander et al., 1988; Meunier and Lewecke, 2005) is accompanied by an increased circulation of the new merged object, compared with each of its components (the total circulation is conserved), and the increase in circulation of trailing vortices as they entrain vorticity from their surroundings has also been shown in the near wake of an oscillating wing(Birch and Lee, 2005).
The near wake is much more readily tied to the generating wing kinematics and it also contains details of vortex structures that could easily be missed in the far wake. For example, the vortex ring generated by the outer wing at the end of the upstroke was clearly visible in the near wake, and although it was also visible in the far wake (when it was known where to look) it had often been moved by convection out of the field of view. Hence, studying only the far wake may lead to an over-simplified view of the wake structure.
Double `start' vortices at 2 m s–1
At 2 m s–1 we observed a novel vortex wake (Figs 3 and 4). Here, the wake contained two consecutive vortices of start (positive sign) sense but only one stop vortex, as seen both at the inner and at the outer wing position. This wake pattern is found at a flight speed where the upstroke is almost vertical relative to still air, which based on kinematics occurs at 2–3 m s–1 (0.43<Strouhal number, St=fA/U<0.75) in this species(Lindhe Norberg and Winter,2006). The upstroke may thus generate thrust or negative thrust,depending on the sign of circulation around the wings. However, when the upstroke is vertical, weight support should be negligible or even negative and the downstroke alone must generate full weight support. At 2.5 m s–1, the wake of the two bats differed, with one displaying the characteristics of 2 m s–1 flight speed and the other the characteristics of 3 m s–1, suggesting some variation between individuals due to small differences in movement patterns of the wings. In the absence of transverse [y, z] velocity field data at this flight speed, we cannot determine how this wake pattern connects in three dimensions or at exactly which phase of the stroke the `start' vortices are formed. Therefore we can only speculate about the origin of the double `start'vortices. One possibility is that it represents two phases of the build-up of the circulation around the wing, one attributed to the rotation of the wing at the end of the upstroke/beginning of the downstroke and the second attributed to the linear acceleration of the wing. A second possibility is that the second `start' vortex represents the shedding of a trailing edge vortex built up during the first part of the downstroke. Shedding of trailing edge vortices has been observed in heaving plate experiments at high St and/or high angles of attack (e.g. Jones and Platzer,1997; Lewin and Haj-Hariri,2003), both criteria being fulfilled by the bats at this flight speed (Hedenström et al.,2007). However, measurements directly above the wing surface in this species have shown a continuous shedding of trailing edge vorticity during the downstroke at 1 m s–1(Muijres et al., 2008) and it needs to be confirmed whether the pattern is indeed qualitatively different at 2 m s–1.
Inverted rings with negative lift – control or unavoidable cost?
Kinematic studies of flying bats have provided a basis for aerodynamic hypotheses (Aldridge, 1986; Aldridge, 1987; von Helversen, 1986; Lindhe Norberg and Winter,2006; Norberg,1976a; Norberg,1976b), including the prediction of negative circulation at the outer wing during the end of the upstroke(Norberg, 1976a; Norberg, 1976b). This was confirmed by Hedenström and colleagues(Hedenström et al.,2007), but not further explored in quantitative detail. In fact,the circulation around the wing during the end of the upstroke differs in sign between the inner and outer part of the wing at medium (4 m s–1) and high speeds (6.5 m s–1). Qualitatively, this means that at some position along the span a vortex core,a distinct patch of streamwise vorticity, of the same sense as a `normal' tip vortex is being shed (blue-filled circle in Fig. 8A), while at the tip of the wing the vortex has opposite-signed circulation (orange-filled circle in Fig. 8A). Because the inner part of the wing generates a downwash, the vortex structure generated here will move downwards. At the same time the outer wing generates an upwash resulting in an upward displacement of the vortex structure generated there(Fig. 8B). This should result in the vortex shed at mid-span being separated into two vortices when moving downstream, which is what is observed in most of the images(Fig. 8C). In a minority of cases, the two vortices are still connected (similar to the blue-filled circles in Fig. 8A). Shedding of trailing vortices along the span is quite common in engineered wings as a result of changes in the pressure distribution over the wing (due to extended flaps, etc.). But in most cases these vortices are the result of changes in the magnitude of the bound circulation rather than its sign.
The fact that the inner and outer part of the wing generate forces in opposite vertical directions might have consequences for the manoeuvring performance of bats. Small spanwise variations in the location of the mid-span vortex may have large consequences for the rolling moments generated by the wing as a means to increase manoeuvrability. Alternatively, the upwash may be generated as a control manoeuvre to correct pitching moments from some other phase of the wing stroke. The ring generated at the outer wing is tilted relative to the horizontal (Fig. 2), and is generated when the wing is in a position far from the centre of mass in the pitch plane [x, z], and thus could be an efficient way of generating a pitching moment. These bats do not have a tail,which might otherwise be responsible for these control moments in birds and other bats with more pronounced tail membranes. In the end it could yet be that generating this vortex is an involuntary consequence of having membranous wings, and therefore represents a cost constraint of bat flight not necessarily shared by other flying animals with non-membranous wings. The cost, as expressed in negative vertical force, is relatively small,representing only 0.4% and 1% of the weight of the bat at the speeds studied here.
At the upper turning point of the wing stroke not only the outer part of the wing but also the inner wing and body generate upward-induced flows. This happens after the outer wing has shed its negative-lift-generating vortex ring and is starting to develop circulation for the downstroke(Fig. 4). For the inner wing the stop vortex at the end of the upstroke encircles the upward flow together with wing root cores formed mid-wing at the beginning of the downstroke by the outer wing and the start vortex of the downstroke. In other words, the upward-directed flow seen at the inner wing and body occurs during the beginning of the downstroke (see above and Fig. 4). In videos of the lateral view the tail/legs move upwards relative to the body, forming a negative geometric angle of attack and the inner wing membrane `bulges'downwards showing a loss of lift or production of negative lift, consistent with the observed wake. Consequently the circulation around all the sections of the wing changes sign during some phase of the stroke cycle. This suggests that the circulation observed in the streamwise plane[x–z], which represents the change in circulation, is able to capture the total circulation generated during a wing beat and can be used to calculate the force balance in these bats.
One ring or two?
At all speeds studied, each bat wing generated its own vortex loop as shown by the presence of the wing root vortices in the transverse [y, z]plane, confirming previous observations(Hedenström et al.,2007). When a wing flaps by rotation about a hinge (the wing root), there are large differences in the relative magnitude of the air flow from root to tip. At the root, the flow can be imagined to be almost steady as local vertical wing section speeds are small compared with the mean forward speed. The relative magnitude of the variation due to the flapping motion itself [and associated local section Reynolds numbers(Rosén et al., 2007)]increases towards the tip. At a local wing section the circulation will also vary in direct proportion to the local incident velocity (subject to modification from local twist, camber, flexibility and thickness) and if the bound circulation changes then so must the circulation deposited into the wake. This section-by-section, quasi-two-dimensional concept of wing circulation makes the formation of two separate rings behind flapping wing pairs quite a likely outcome, and many such complicated wake structures have been reported in the insect flight literature (e.g. Aono et al., 2008; Brodsky, 1991; Grodnitsky and Morozov, 1993). However, the shedding and subsequent roll-up of shed vorticity is not easy to predict and may be very different from a quasi-two-dimensional process.
Here, the measured spanwise variations in wake circulation are consistent with the observation that each bat wing makes (at least) one ring of its own. Far-wake measurements of birds in similar circumstances do not show such circulation gradients and have not found significant drops in wake circulation at the centreline. However, a recent study of swift wakes shows a reduction of the induced downwash behind the body relative to that of the wings(Henningsson et al., 2008),which should be indicative of wing root vortices. There are no conclusive data from transverse planes in bird wakes, and although the existing models based on far-wake measurements of bird flight have single loops for each wing pair,it may be that higher resolution data in transverse planes and closer to the animal might show this to be an oversimplified concept.
We thank P. Henningsson for comments on parts of the manuscript. This work was supported by grants from the Swedish Research Council, the Swedish Foundation for International Cooperation in Research and Higher Education, the Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation, the Crafoord Foundation, the Magnus Bergvall Foundation, the Royal Physiographical Society in Lund, and the Volkswagen Stiftung. The experiments were approved by the Lund University ethical board (M153-05).