SUMMARY
Several genes containing the conserved T-box region in invertebrates and vertebrates have been reported recently. Here, we describe three novel members of the T-box gene family in zebrafish. One of these genes, tbx-c, is studied in detail. It is expressed in the axial mesoderm, notably, in the notochordal precursor cells immediately before formation of the notochord and in the chordoneural hinge of the tail bud, after the notochord is formed. In addition, its expression is detected in the ventral forebrain, sensory neurons, fin buds and excretory system. The expression pattern of tbx-c differs from that of the other two related genes, tbx-a and tbx-b.
The developmental role of tbx-c has been analysed by overexpression of the full-length tbx-c mRNA and a truncated form of tbx-c mRNA, which encodes the dominant-negative Tbx-c. Overexpression of tbx-c causes expansion of the midline mesoderm and formation of ectopic midline structures at the expense of lateral mesodermal cells. In dominant-negative experiments, the midline mesoderm is reduced with the expansion of lateral mesoderm to the midline. These results suggest that tbx-c plays a role in formation of the midline mesoderm, particularly, the notochord. Moreover, modulation of tbx-c activity alters the development of primary motor neurons.
Results of in vitro analysis in zebrafish animal caps suggest that tbx-c acts downstream of early mesodermal inducers (activin and ntl) and reveal an autoregulatory feedback loop between ntl and tbx-c. These data and analysis of midline (ntl−/− and flh−/−) and lateral mesoderm (spt−/−) mutants suggest that tbx-c may function during formation of the notochord.
INTRODUCTION
During gastrulation in vertebrate embryos, three definitive germ layers (ectoderm, mesoderm and endoderm) are formed by organized and coordinated cell movements. In zebrafish, further subdivision of mesoderm gives rise to axial, adaxial and paraxial mesoderm. The axial mesoderm contributes to the prechordal plate and notochord whereas the adaxial and paraxial cells give rise to different types of muscles (Devoto et al., 1996; Blagden et al., 1997; Currie and Ingham, 1998). In recent years, T-box genes, which encode transcriptional regulatory proteins containing the conserved DNA-binding domain (T-domain), have gained attention as they have been shown to play an essential role in the specification and differentiation of early mesoderm (Papaioannou and Silver, 1998). Brachyury (T), a founder member of the vertebrate T-box gene family, regulates the specification and differentiation of posterior mesoderm during gastrulation (Herrmann, 1995). Furthermore, maternally expressed T-box gene, VegT alone controls the pattern of primary germ layer specification in Xenopus embryos (Zhang et al., 1998). Recently, murine Tbx6 has been shown to be required for cells to choose between mesodermal and neuronal differentiation during gastrulation (Chapman and Papaioannou, 1998). All these data establish the proteins encoded by T-box genes as the molecular switches acting in various cell lineages during determination of cell fates.
Fate mapping has shown that the embryonic shield (the zebrafish organizer) contains future dorsal derivatives, including mesodermal and ectodermal lineages (Kimmel et al., 1990; Shih and Fraser, 1995). It has been reported that cell groups in the organizer region are under the control of zygotically expressed genes (Krauss et al., 1993; Strähle et al., 1993; Ekker et al., 1995; Weinberg et al., 1996). Expression patterns of these genes reflect the functional complexity of the organizer region. For example, gsc is specifically expressed in the primordium of the anterior axial mesoderm that contributes to the prechordal plate (Stachel et al., 1993; Thisse et al., 1994). Conversely, ntl, a Brachyury homologue and flh, a homeobox gene, are expressed in the prospective posterior axial mesoderm that forms the notochord (Schutle-Merker et al., 1994; Talbot et al., 1995). Analysis of the zebrafish mutants, ntl−/− and flh−/−, has revealed that both of these genes play essential roles in notochord development (Halpern et al., 1993, 1995; Talbot et al., 1995). Recent analysis of flh;ntl double mutant embryos suggests that Ntl may function in the cell fate choice between the notochord and the floor plate, whereas Flh may act in the choice between the notochord and the muscle (Halpern et al., 1997). Furthermore, the T-box genes, ntl and spt, interact antagonistically during specification of the notochord and paraxial mesoderm (Amacher and Kimmel, 1998; Griffin et al., 1998).
Here we present three novel zebrafish T-box-containing genes, tbx-a, tbx-b and tbx-c, which are related to the Drosophila optomotor-blind (omb) gene, a member of the T-box gene family (Pflugfelder et al., 1992). The three zebrafish T-box genes form, within the T-box gene family, a subfamily of omb-related genes. Expression patterns of the omb-related genes in mouse and chick have been reported (Chapman et al., 1996; Gibson-Brown et al., 1996), but the functions of these genes are largely unknown. More recently, chick Tbx2 has been shown to act in the lateral mesoderm during early limb development (Gibson-Brown et al., 1998).
We describe the expression pattern of tbx-c in wild-type embryos as well as ntl−/−, flh−/− and spt−/− embryos and the results of both gain-of-function and loss-of-function experiments, which produce nearly opposite effects. In addition, we studied regulation of tbx-c expression and its interaction with mesodermal determinants in an animal cap assay. These results reveal that tbx-c plays a role in the specification of late notochordal precursor cells and formation of the differentiated notochord.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Animals
Wild-type zebrafish embryos were obtained from the fish facility of the Institute of Molecular Agrobiology (IMA), Singapore. Mutant embryos were obtained from fish lines established in the IMA. Heterozygous mutant fish, larvae and embryos were kindly provided by Drs C. Kimmel, B. Trevarrow, M. Halpern, D. Grunwald, U. Strähle and H.-G. Frohnhoefer. The developmental stages are presented as hours postfertilisation (hpf) (Westerfield, 1995; Kimmel et al., 1995).
Cloning and sequencing
A cDNA clone of 1.8 kb encoding a T-box-related gene that lacks the 5′-terminal of the coding region was initially identified by random sequencing from the cDNA library of mixed stages (Gong et al., 1997) and was named the zebrafish tbx-c. After sequencing, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was performed using a specific reverse primer (5′-ACCATCCAGCGAGAGTTG-3′) and forward T3 primer in order to amplify the full-length coding sequence of tbx-c from the cDNA library. One of two cDNA fragments obtained was identified as the 5′-terminal of tbx-c and used to generate the full-length cDNA of tbx-c (GenBank accession number AF 136946). The second cDNA fragment, which contains 700 nucleotides at the 5′-terminal including a part of the T-box, is distinct from the tbx-c and has been named as tbx-a. In addition, screening of an embryonic 24 hpf zebrafish cDNA gridded library (Max-Planck-Institute of Molecular Genetics, Berlin, Germany) by high-stringency hybridization (using tbx-c as a probe) resulted in isolation of another cDNA clone containing a partial coding region of a third T-box gene. This clone, which lacks the 5′-terminal, was named tbx-b. Both strands of these clones were sequenced by the dideoxy chain termination method using the T7 Sequencing Kit (Pharmacia, Sweden). Sequences were analyzed using DNA Works, Clustal and MacVector softwares. Work is in progress to obtain the complete coding regions of tbx-a and tbx-b.
Whole-mount in situ hybridization and immunohistochemistry
Whole-mount in situ hybridization using RNA probes labelled with digoxigenin (Dig; Boehringer Mannheim, Germany) was carried out as previously reported by Oxtoby and Jowett (1993). The stained embryos were cryosectioned (10-15 μm), when necessary. After whole-mount in situ hybridization, some embryos were stained with an anti-Pan-islet antibody and anti-ntl antibody as described previously (Korzh et al., 1993; Schulte-Merker et al., 1992). Two-colour in situ hybridization was carried out according to protocol kindly provided by Dr Elke Ober, Tubingen, Germany.
Synthesis of capped mRNA and microinjection
cDNAs encoding either full-length (tbx-c+) or truncated (dn-tbx-c) tbx-c were subcloned into the pSP64T vector (a gift of Dr D. Melton). The dn-tbx-c construct was made by deleting the 3′-terminal region of tbx-c from the position of Pro306. The plasmids were linearized and the capped RNAs were synthesized using the mESSAGE mACHINE SP6 transcription kit (Ambion, USA). Activin mRNA was synthesized using linearised pSP64T-XActivin β plasmid (a gift of Dr D. Melton). Unless otherwise stated (see Figure Legends), 1 ng of tbx-c+ and dn-tbx-c, or 100 pg of β-gal synthetic RNAs (as controls) were injected into embryos at the 1- to 2-cell stage. After injection, embryos were allowed to develop at 28°C and then fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde (PFA) at the stages indicated.
Animal cap assay
Zebrafish animal caps were isolated as reported by Sagerström et al. (1996), with minor modifications. Briefly, embryos at the 1- to 2-cell stage were injected with tbx-c+ (1 ng), ntl (800 pg), activin (2 or 7 pg) or lacZ (100 pg) mRNA and left to develop until the late blastula stage (4 hpf). The caps were dissected and incubated in a L15 Leibovitz medium (Sigma, USA) supplemented with 10% horse serum and antibiotic (100 U Penicillin-100 μg Streptomycin/ml; GIBCO BRL, USA,) at 28°C and harvested at various stages. The caps were fixed in 4% PFA and analyzed by whole-mount in situ hybridization.
RESULTS
Sequence analysis
Three novel zebrafish T-box genes from the omb-related subfamily were isolated and sequenced as described in Materials and Methods. The conceptual protein sequence of zebrafish tbx-c consists of 672 amino acid (aa) residues (Fig. 1A). Alignment with sequences of mouse Tbx2, Drosophila Omb, zebrafish Ntl and Xenopus ET within the T-domain shows that the T-domain of zebrafish Tbx-c is more closely related to murine Tbx2 than to ET, Omb or Ntl (Fig. 1B,E). Furthermore, the BLAST homology analysis (Altschul et al., 1997) revealed that the C-terminal end, excluding the T-domain, of tbx-c has similarity only with mouse Tbx2. Overall, the open reading frame of this clone has 70.2% conservation in comparison to that of mouse Tbx2.
Expression pattern of tbx-c
The pattern of expression of tbx-c in the wild-type zebrafish embryos has been studied by whole-mount in situ hybridization. Weak expression of tbx-c was first detected in the axial mesoderm at 80% epiboly (not shown). At the end of gastrulation, tbx-c expression was observed in the prospective ventral forebrain, the single eye field and the presumptive notochord (Fig. 2A,B). By 12 hpf, the eye field has separated at the midline into two tbx-c-positive domains of expression (not shown). At 20 hpf, tbx-c expression in the eye was found to be restricted to the dorsal retina (Fig. 2C,E). In addition, tbx-c expression was evident in the epiphysis, otic vesicles and sensory neurons of cranial ganglia including the trigeminal, and the anterior and the posterior lateral line ganglia (Fig. 2C,E,F). In the dorsal spinal cord, tbx-c expression mapped to the population of mechanosensory Rohon-Beard (RB) cells (Figs 2G, 3A). Posteriorly, the tbx-c transcripts were localized to the excretory system (Figs 2G, 3A). At 22 hpf, tbx-c expression was detected in buds of pectoral fins (Fig. 2D) and, at 30 hpf, in a subset of interneurons in the anterior spinal cord (not shown).
After 12 hpf, expression of tbx-c in the midline was found only at the posterior end of the notochord where it could be detected until the end of segmentation (Fig. 3A,D,F,G). The midline precursor cells in the tail bud form a bulb-like structure and segregate into specific cell lineages to form midline tissues, the notochord, the hypochord and the floor plate. Morphologically (Pasteels, 1943; D′Amico and Cooper, 1997) and genetically by the expression of flh and ntl (Gont et al., 1996; Catala et al., 1995, 1996), this structure has been defined as the chordoneural hinge (CNH). As differentiation of the notochord proceeds, the round-shaped early midline precursor cells in the posterior region of the CNH transform into the oval-shaped cells. These cells further undergo morphological changes and become spindle-shaped cells, characteristic of the notochord (Fig. 3H).
The expression pattern of tbx-c differs from that of other two T-box genes presented in this study. In the posterior body, tbx-c was expressed in the CNH, RB cells and the excretory system (Fig. 3A), whereas expression of tbx-b and tbx-a mapped to the differentiated notochord (Fig. 3B) and excretory system (Fig. 3C), respectively. This suggests that these three genes may have specific functions during formation of the posterior body.
The timing of expression of several developmental genes in the midline precursor cells correlates with important events of notochordal morphogenesis such as differentiation and formation of the notochord. These genes, including shh, ntl and flh, are expressed in discrete regions of the CNH. At 20 hpf, expression of Ntl was localized to early mesodermal cells, the CNH as well as the notochord (Fig. 3D,H; Schulte-Merker et al., 1992). shh expression was found in the CNH, the notochord and the floor plate (Fig. 3E). In contrast, flh expression was confined to the posterior region of the CNH containing round-shaped cells (Fig. 3F,H). Interestingly, tbx-c expression was localized to the oval-shaped cells in the anterior region of the CNH (Fig. 3D,F-H) and ceased once the oval-shaped cells were transformed into spindle-shaped cells of the notochord. Expression of tbx-c and flh was found in adjacent domains of the CNH and these domains partially overlap in the middle of the CNH (Fig. 3F).
tbx-c acts during specification of axial mesoderm
Tbx-c contains the highly conserved T-domain, which may be involved in DNA binding, similar to Bra and omb (Kispert and Herrmann, 1993; Pflugfelder et al., 1992) (Fig. 1A). It was shown that removal of the 3′-terminal region of the Bra gene, encoding the transactivation (TA) domain produces a dominant-negative mRNA with antimorphic effects (Stott et al., 1993; Rao, 1994). We used a similar strategy to synthesize dn-tbx-c mRNA encoding a truncated protein. We also synthesized a full-length tbx-c mRNA. These mRNAs were injected into zebrafish embryos, which were analyzed by whole-mount in situ hybridization using specific molecular markers for mesodermal (Table 1A,B) and neuroectodermal derivatives.
Mesoderm
First, the effect of tbx-c was analyzed using midline markers shh and ntl (Fig. 4A-H). ntl is expressed in the undifferentiated mesoderm and the notochord (Schulte-Merker et al., 1992) (Fig. 4A). shh is expressed in the notochord (Fig. 4D,G), the prechordal plate and the ventral neural tube (Krauss et al., 1993). As revealed by these markers, the midline mesoderm was expanded mediolaterally in the tbx-c+ embryos (Fig. 4B,E). In contrast, dn-tbx-c acts antimorphically, causing attenuation of the midline (Fig. 4C,F). Some embryos injected with tbx-c+ mRNA displayed axis bifurcation anteriorly (Fig. 4H). Multiple notochords were observed in about 20% (12 out of 61) of the embryos injected with a higher dose (3 ng) of tbx-c+ mRNA (Fig. 5B), indicating that the effect of tbx-c on axis formation is dose-dependent.
We next examined the effect of tbx-c+ on formation of other mesodermal derivatives. tbx6 and spt, T-box containing genes, are co-expressed in the ventrolateral paraxial mesoderm contributing to somites (Hug et al., 1997; Griffin et al., 1998; Fig. 4I,L). Expression of these genes was reduced in tbx-c+ embryos (Fig. 4J,M) and expanded across the midline in dn-tbx-c embryos (Fig. 4K,N). myoD expression maps to adaxial and paraxial cells of somites (Weinberg et al., 1996; Fig. 4O,R). The tbx-c+ embryos displayed a broader midline surrounded by adaxial cells and partially or completely reduced somitic tissue (Fig. 4P,S). In dn-tbx-c embryos, somites were fused at the dorsal midline and often expanded laterally (Fig. 4Q,T). Transverse sections reveal the presence of myoD-positive cells at the midline of dn-tbx-c embryos. These results suggest that tbx-c acts by promoting midline axial fates and suppressing lateral mesodermal fates.
Motor neurons (MNs)
It has been reported that local signals from the notochord induce differentiation of MNs (Placzek et al., 1990; Yamada et al., 1993; Ericson et al., 1992; Goulding et al., 1993). We have analyzed whether ectopic expression of tbx-c+ and dn-tbx-c influences specification of these neurons.
In wild-type embryos, MNs are arranged in a row on both sides of the midline and express islet1 (Korzh et al., 1993; Inoue et al., 1994; Appel et al., 1995; Fig. 5A,D). Embryos injected with tbx-c+ displayed a substantial increase in the number of MNs (40%; 26/65). Several of these embryos developed 3-4 lines of MNs along the midline (not shown). The frequency of extranumerary MNs was increased when a higher dose of tbx-c+ mRNA (3 ng) was injected. Double staining for ntl and Islet1 confirmed the increase in the number of MNs with expanded or extranumerary notochords in tbx-c+ embryos (Fig. 5B,E). Conversely, number of MNs was significantly reduced (36%; 20/55; Fig. 5C,F) in dn-tbx-c embryos. Loss of Islet-1-positive MNs correlates with decrease or lack of ntl expression in the dorsal midline.
To examine whether tbx-c+can rescue phenotypes caused by the injection of dn-tbx-c mRNA, we next injected tbx-c+ and dn-tbx-c mRNAs together (1 ng each) into embryos and analyzed these embryos by in situ hybridization with myoD and ntl probes. This experiment showed that tbx-c+ rescued phenotypes caused by dn-tbx-c in a majority of injected embryos (Table 1C).
In order to address possible regulatory interactions between tbx-c and other notochordal determinants, we analyzed expression of tbx-c in mutant embryos lacking Ntl and Flh. In ntl−/− mutants, the midline mesoderm was segregated from the paraxial mesoderm (Fig. 6B) as in wild-type embryos (Fig. 6A). Weak expression of tbx-c was found in the midline mesoderm of mutants (Fig. 6B). We injected tbx-c+ into a pool of unidentified embryos (88 embryos) derived from the heterozygous ntl−/+ pair (ntlb160) to study whether tbx-c can induce differentiation of notochord cells in the absence of ntl. At 11 hpf, embryos were stained for ehh mRNA, a marker for differentiated notochord (Currie and Ingham, 1996; V. K., unpublished data), followed by Ntl protein (Fig. 6C) to distinguish mutant embryos. Control ntl−/− embryos (ntlb160) do not express ehh mRNA and Ntl protein (not shown). Similarly, injected ntl−/− embryos (18/88 embryos) did not express both ehh and Ntl (Fig. 6D). In contrast, wild-type siblings of ntl−/− embryos showed expression of ehh and Ntl in the expanded notochord caused by the injection of tbx-c+ (Fig. 6E). This result indicates that tbx-c can promote differentiation of notochord only in the presence of ntl.
In flh−/− mutants, there was no segregation of midline and paraxial mesoderm and tbx-c expression was completely absent in the midline (Fig. 6F). The injection of tbx-c+ did not induce notochord formation in flh−/− embryos as revealed by the expression of ntl (Fig. 6H). A few ntl-positive cells were found in the midline of both uninjected (Fig. 6G) and injected flh−/− embryos at 11 hpf. This result suggests that flh is required for the function of tbx-c. In both mutants, tbx-c expression appeared to be unaltered in anterior structures including the eye field and the ventral neural keel compared to the wild-type embryos.
As spt expression was strongly reduced in tbx-c+ embryos, we analyzed tbx-c expression in spt−/− embryos, which are deficient of trunk somites (Kimmel et al., 1989). tbx-c expression in spt−/− (Fig. 6J) embryos was similar to the wild-type expression pattern (Fig. 6I). However, the notochord in spt−/− embryos appeared to be widened as already reported (Amacher and Kimmel, 1998; Warga and Nusslein-Volhard, 1998).
Analysis of tbx-c regulation in animal caps
It has been shown that the expression of several genes encoding T-related proteins in Xenopus (VegT, Eomes and
Xbra) and in zebrafish (Ntl and Tbx6) is responsive to the dorsal mesodermal inducer, Activin. In Xenopus animal caps, Activin can respecify prospective ectodermal tissue to form different mesodermal cell types in a dose-dependent manner. Moreover, Activin can function in the embryo as a long-range morphogen (Gurdon et al., 1994, 1995; Jones et al., 1996; Reilly and Melton, 1996; Hug et al., 1997; for review see Smith, 1997).
In our experiments, expression of ntl and tbx-c was induced in animal caps dissected from the embryos injected with activin mRNA (Fig. 7B,D). There was no transcription of either ntl or tbx-c in the control caps (Fig. 7A,C). These data suggest that tbx-c, like ntl, can be a downstream target gene of general mesoderm inducers like Activin.
During normal development, ntl is expressed much earlier than tbx-c (Schulte-Merker et al., 1992). Correspondingly, ntl transcripts accumulated much faster than that of tbx-c in animal caps injected with activin mRNA. This suggests that activation of tbx-c expression can be mediated by ntl which is induced by activin mRNA. To test this possibility, we injected ntl RNA and assessed tbx-c expression in animal caps derived from injected embryos. tbx-c was strongly induced in these caps (Fig.7E). These results indicate that ntl acts upstream of tbx-c and can induce its transcription. In contrast, changes in ntl expression observed in whole embryos after injection of tbx-c+ and dn-tbx-c RNA suggest that tbx-c can regulate ntl expression. It seems that tbx-c function is necessary for the maintenance of ntl expression in the notochord via a positive feed-back regulatory loop. We further found that tbx-c+ can induce ntl expression in animal caps (Fig. 7F). However, tbx-c is not essential for the activation of ntl expression by the early mesoderm inducer, since ntl expression was induced in animal caps derived from embryos injected with activin and dn-tbx-c together (Fig. 7G). This result further suggests that effects of dn-tbx-c are attributed to the specific function of tbx-c.
DISCUSSION
Analysis of the structure of three T-box genes presented here reveals that they belong to the subfamily of zebrafish omb-related genes. The founder gene of this subfamily, omb, plays an essential role in development of the optic lobe and the distal wing of Drosophila (Pflugfelder et al., 1992; Grimm and Pflugfelder, 1996). A number of omb-related genes has been identified in many species, including ET in Xenopus, and Tbx2 and Tbx3 in chick, mice and human (Agulnik et al., 1995; Campbell et al., 1995; Law et al 1995; Li et al., 1997; Gibson-Brown et al., 1996; for review see Papaioannou and Silver, 1998). Among the T-box genes identified in vertebrates so far, only Bra/ntl is expressed in the notochord (Papaioannou and Silver, 1998). In contrast, tbx-c is expressed not only in the notochord but also in other cell lineages including the CNS, the limb and the excretory system. Amino acid sequence comparison suggests that tbx-c is closely related to Tbx2 of higher vertebrates. However, the expression pattern of tbx-c differs from that of Tbx2 identified in other species.
Tbx-c acts as a determinant of midline mesoderm
The unique expression pattern of tbx-c in the CNH suggests that tbx-c has a potential role in morphogenesis and differentiation of midline structures, especially the notochord. This was confirmed by functional experiments that include overexpression of full-length as well as dominant-negative Tbx-c. Changes in the midline of tbx-c+ and dn-tbx-c embryos indicate that Tbx-c is important for specification of midline precursor cells and formation of the notochord. The concurrent reduction of somites in tbx-c+ embryos and their partial fusion at the midline in dn-tbx-c embryos provides evidence that Tbx-c, similar to Flh, may promote axial fates by acting in the cell fate choice between axial and lateral mesoderm.
Moreover, stage-specific expression of flh in the early CNH and tbx-c in the late CNH suggests that these genes can be responsible for distinct phases of notochord differentiation. It is also possible that both Flh and Tbx-c may act synergistically in the regulation of differentiation of midline precursor cells initiated by early inducers of dorsal mesoderm such as Ntl, since the ectopic effects of Tbx-c and Flh homologue in Xenopus (Gont et al., 1996) on notochord development are similar. Probably, initiation of tbx-c expression is not dependent on flh as tbx-c is expressed in several cell lineages that do not express flh. In addition, the role of tbx-c differs from that of flh since tbx-c+ could not rescue the notochord in flh−/− embryos.
Analysis of tbx-c expression in ntl−/− embryos suggests that Ntl may not be involved in initiation of tbx-c expression. However, finding of the positive regulatory loop between tbx-c and ntl in the present study indicates that, during development of the notochord, Ntl may be essential for the maintenance of tbx-c expression and vice versa.
The gain-of-function phenotype observed in the present study is reminiscent to that of zebrafish spt−/− embryos that fail to form trunk somites but form a wider notochord (Kimmel et al., 1989; Thisse et al., 1995; Griffin et al., 1998). spt function appears to be essential for the development of the relative size of the axial and paraxial fields (Warga and Nusslein-Volhard, 1998). In the same fashion, it can be speculated that tbx-c may be responsible for establishing the relative size of the notochord, since the size of the notochord was altered in tbx-c+ and dn-tbx-c embryos. In addition, suppression of spt expression in tbx-c+ embryos suggests that Spt and Tbx-c act antagonistically during specification and segregation of axial and paraxial mesoderm lineages, like Flh and Spt (Amacher and Kimmel, 1998).
Tbx-c acts as a stage-specific regulator during notochord differentiation
The principal roles of two T-box genes, ntl and tbx-c, during mesoderm development may differ since their expression patterns are distinct. ntl is expressed in undifferentiated mesodermal cells and subsequently in the notochord. These data, together with mutant analysis suggest that the functional role of Ntl is limited to the notochord where it acts as a lineage-specific factor. In contrast, tbx-c is expressed in the CNH as well as in other cell lineages outside the mesoderm. Therefore, it is suggested that Tbx-c may function as a stage-specific differentiation factor during formation of the notochord. A number of developmentally important molecules including Flh and Islet1 function in a similar fashion in several cell lineages (Talbot et al., 1995; Pfaff et al., 1996; Masai et al., 1997).
Regulation of Tbx-c influences differentiation of primary motor neurons
Sonic hedgehog (Shh), a secreted protein of the hedgehog family (Hh), is expressed in the midline precursor cells during gastulation and subsequently in the differentiated notochord and floor plate (Krauss et al., 1993). shh appears to induce differentiation of a subset of neurons in the ventral neural tube (Krauss et al., 1993; Roelink et al., 1994; Ekker et al., 1995; Hammerschmidt et al., 1996). Early specification of primary MNs takes place before formation of the differentiated notochord and has been suggested to depend on Hh signaling from midline precursor cells (Appel et al., 1995; Hammerschmidt et al., 1996; Beattie et al., 1997). These reports led us to speculate that the overproduction of MNs observed in tbx-c+ embryos could be due to increased
expression of Hh caused by expansion of the midline. In dn-tbx-c embryos, synthesis of Hh might be reduced as a result of attenuation of midline structures, thereby resulting in a reduced number of MNs. Therefore, it is suggested that the effect of Tbx-c on development of MNs can be mediated via Hh signaling. This is interesting in connection with recent observations that Drosophila omb and chick Tbx2 are regulated by Hh (Kopp and Duncan, 1997; Gibson-Brown et al., 1996).
Alternatively, reduced expression of tbx6 in tbx-c+ embryos could also be the causative factor for the formation of extranumerary MNs since a mutation in the mouse Tbx6 induces ectopic neural tissue including MNs, at the expense of somitic tissue (Chapman and Papaioannou, 1998). However, further analysis is required to determine the possible molecular mechanisms and involvment of Tbx-c in MNs development.
A regulatory feedback loop involving Tbx-c is required for specification of midline structures
Our finding of an autoregulatory loop between ntl and tbx-c adds a new element to the understanding of mechanism of notochordal specification in zebrafish. The early mesodermal induction triggered by maternally expressed TGF-β and FGFs, activates early function of T-box genes such as VegT and Bra (Smith et al., 1991; Zhang et al., 1998). ntl/Bra interacts with eFGF in a positive regulatory feedback loop (Isaacs et al., 1994; Schulte-Merker and Smith, 1995) and acts synergistically with HNF-3β-related proteins (O’Reilly et al., 1995) to induce development of dorsal mesoderm. It seems that further development of the notochord requires stage-specific regulators including flh and tbx-c. Flh and Tbx-c act to equilibrate the antagonistic influence of determinants of the lateral mesoderm such as tbx6/spt in order to specify the identity of the notochordal cells (Hug et al., 1997; Chapman and Papaioannou, 1998; Amacher and Kimmel, 1998; Griffin et al., 1998). Similar antagonistic interactions could exist between specific regulators of the notochord and floor plate as well as the notochord and hypochord.
In this paper, we have described three novel genes that belong to the subfamily of omb-related zebrafish T-box genes. The expression pattern and functional analysis of tbx-c suggests that Tbx-c acts immediately before formation of the notochord and may be involved in the process of notochordal differentiation.
Acknowledgments
Authors are indebted to Drs Doug Melton, C. Kimmel, David Grunwald, Steve Ekker, Eric Weinberg, Stefan Schulte-Merker, Bill Trevarrow, Hans-Georg Frohnhoefer, Marnie Halpern, Uwe Strähle and Will Talbot for providing cDNA constructs and mutant lines. We are also thankful to Drs Uwe Strähle, David Grunwald, Lila Solnica-Krezel, Laszlo Orban and Karuna Sampath for discussions and comments on the manuscript and Ms.Poon Kar Lai for technical assistance and animal care. We appreciate two anonymous reviewers whose constructive comments were useful to improve this manuscript significantly. This work was supported by a grant from the National Science and Technology Board of Singapore.
Note added in proof
During preparation of this manuscript a partial sequence of the zebrafish tbx-3 gene has been published (Yonei-Tamura et al., 1999). Within 188aa of the incomplete T-domain of zf-tbx3 reported, we found only one aa mismatch comparing it to the corresponding region of the Tbx3-related tbx-b described here. This fact and similarity of expression of these two clones in the differentiated notochord suggests that the zf-tbx3 and our tbx-b may represent independent isolates of the same gene.